Labour MSP Neil Bibby lodges draft proposal for tied pub tenants

March 14th, 2017 | Posted in: News

Labour MSP Neil Bibby has lodged a draft proposal  in Holyrood backed by the  Scottish Licensed Trade Association, the Campaign for Real Ale and GMB Scotland, who all believe his proposal would make it fairer for tenants of pubs who have a ‘tied’ arrangement with pubcos. This would affect some 1,000 pubs in Scotland which are currently tenanted. A consultation on the proposal is set to open on Monday.

Under the current arrangements, tenants often have a contractual obligation to buy some or all products from the pubco that they lease from.  But MSP Neil Bibby’s draft proposal would bring Scotland into line with their counterparts in England and Wales, who now have a statutory Pub Code with has introduced more relaxed rules for licensees.

The MSP has lodged the draft proposal despite a new voluntary code recently being introduced in Scotland. The new Scottish code does not go as far as the statutory code in England and Wales.

Scottish Labour MSP Neil Bibby said, “This proposal is about fairness, choice and jobs. Fairness for Scotland’s publicans, greater choice for pub customers, and an opportunity to protect and create jobs in Scotland’s pub and brewing industry.

He continues, “Scottish pub tenants should have the ability to opt out of the tied arrangements if they wish. I know from speaking with tied pub tenants in my own area in the west of Scotland how one-sided these arrangements can be.

“Access to a fair and reasonable market rent for premises, without strings attached, should be a right for Scottish publicans. They will then be free to source and purchase products as they see fit, on the same basis as other pubs in Scotland, and pubs in England and Wales.

“Times are tough in the pub sector. Scottish licensees that choose to opt out should have the flexibility they need in a crowded and competitive market place to react to changes that could affect their business – from new pubs opening in their area to changes in the way people socialise. My proposal would give them that flexibility.”

Paul Waterson, chief executive of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association, said, “The SLTA are delighted to support Neil Bibby’s bill advocating protection for Scottish pub tenants. It is only fair that Scottish tenants are afforded the same rights and safeguards as their counterparts in England and Wales.”

Colin Valentine, CAMRA’s National Chairman, commented, “CAMRA fully welcomes the new consultation that has been launched into the tied pub sector by Neil Bibby. We expect that it will paint a picture of pubs struggling to survive across Scotland, with examples of large pub companies taking more than is fair or sustainable from individual publicans’ profits.”

While GMB Scotland Organiser Martin Doran said, “GMB Scotland supports the proposed Tied Pubs Bill because by tackling the pubco giants, it can deliver fairness for tied pubs tenants, give more choice for punters and help create a more level playing field for Scottish brewers.

“This intervention is not before time and our members will warmly welcome Neil Bibby’s efforts to bring about changes to the industry that can only benefit Scottish jobs and the Scottish economy in the long run.”

A consultation on the proposed Tied Pubs (Code and Adjudicator) (Scotland) Bill will formally open on Monday 20 February 2017 and will run to Tuesday 20 June 2017. The consultation document is attached.

At the end of the consultation period, all the responses will be analysed. Neil Bibby MSP then expects to lodge a final proposal in the Parliament along with a summary of those responses.

If that final proposal secures the support of at least 18 other MSPs from at least half of the political parties or groups represented in the Parliamentary Bureau, and the Scottish Government does not indicate that it intends to legislate in the area in question, he will then have the right to introduce a Member’s Bill.

A number of months may be required to finalise the Bill and related documentation. Once introduced, a Member’s Bill follows a three-stage scrutiny process, during which it may be amended or rejected outright. If it is passed at the end of the process, it becomes an Act.

The following two tabs change content below.
Susan Young
Susan Young is a journalist who has spent the last 20 years editing the DRAM. Prior to that, she spent a decade working in Public Relations and Events dealing with clients as diverse as Cumbernauld Development Agency and James Burrough Distillers. Her knowledge of the Scottish licensed trade is extensive and she also instigated the first ever Scottish licensed trade awards which have evolved into the Scottish Bar and Pub Awards.


2017 Award Winners In Full

Wed 16th August 2017

DRAM Lifetime Achievement Linda Johnston – Auchrannie Hotel & Resort BII Customer Service Award Atlantic Bar & Brasserie, Glas... Read more.

Glasgow Pips Edinburgh for Most Gongs at Scottish Bar and Pub Awards

Wed 16th August 2017

Scotland’s licensed trade celebrated in style at the Scottish Bar and Pub Awards on August 15th after the crème de la crème of the i... Read more.

Dug ‘n’ Duck for Millerston

Wed 9th August 2017

The Dug ‘n’ Duck, a new venture between Punch and local couple Ian and Irene Knotts, has taken the place of The New Inn in Mille... Read more.

Buzzworks Recruitment Drive Tonight!

Wed 9th August 2017

Buzzworks Holdings is holding a special event in Kilmarnock this evening aimed at recruiting 40 new members of staff. One of Scotland’... Read more.

August Round Up

Wed 9th August 2017

There was street art, street food and quality rum aplenty at Flor de Cana’s recent Rum Frontiers event, where bartender Ryan Rhodes, of Du... Read more.

Revamp for Hutchesons

Tue 8th August 2017

Rusk & Rusk have revamped and reopened their Merchant City venue Hutchesons and introduced Hutchesons The City Grill. First opened in 20... Read more.

£15m Spend on Queensferry Hotel

Tue 8th August 2017

The Shore Grill & Fish House has been unveiled as part of a £15 million investment at The Queensferry Hotel. The Shore, an open-plan ba... Read more.

Sue Says: August 2017

Mon 7th August 2017

Sue Says: Our editor Susan Young has her say on the industry this month. This time of year it is all about the awards … and over the cours... Read more.

August News Shorts

Mon 7th August 2017

Have a wee read of our news shorts from August! No Hyding on George Street Hyde & Son Coffee Bar and Lounge has opened up within Eden Lo... Read more.

Stats Show Continued Innis & Gunn Growth

Mon 7th August 2017

New figures released by Innis & Gunn reveal that the independent craft brewer increased its group turnover from £11.8m to £14.3m last ... Read more.

August Brand News: Gin

Sun 6th August 2017

Pickering’s Gin & Edinburgh Festival Fringe launch exclusive bottling Pickering’s Gin has launched an exclusive bottling with Edinbu... Read more.

Design Focus: The Coach House

Sat 5th August 2017

The Coach House: 31 Main Street, Bridge of Weir The Coach House, a sophisticated bar/restaurant in Bridge of Weir, is Buzzworks Holdings’ ... Read more.

August Brand News: Whisky

Sat 5th August 2017

Douglas McGibbon Rebrand Douglas McGibbon & Co has rebranded its Clan Denny Single Malt and Single Grain Scotch Whisky range. The new-lo... Read more.

Brand News: Market Report

Fri 4th August 2017

WM Grant Publish Annual Report Wm Grant & Sons published their 2017 Annual Report last month and revealed it to members of the trade at ... Read more.

Raasay Distillery Coming Next Month

Fri 4th August 2017

A brand-new distillery will open on Raasay next month, and it’s expected to employ 10% of the Hebridean island’s population! Isl... Read more.

Leith Wine Cafe To Launch Next Week

Fri 4th August 2017

Leith’s first wine cafe is set to open at The Shore next Tuesday. Already a hub for numerous popular restaurants and bars, the trendy ... Read more.

Design Focus: The Brae

Fri 4th August 2017

The Brae: 26 Townfoot, Dreghorn, Irvine KA11 4EG Take a quaint Ayrshire village with a shortage of eating out options, a boarded up pub wit... Read more.

Brand News: Beer

Thu 3rd August 2017

Heverlee Debuts Packaged Product If you were in Edinburgh over the weekend of the 21st July you may have seen the transformation by Heverlee... Read more.

The Greatest Job Interview In The World?

Thu 3rd August 2017

Grant’s Whisky are sending three candidates on a world tour as part of the interview process for their Global Brand Ambassador vacancy... Read more.

Design Focus: Monty’s

Thu 3rd August 2017

Monty’s: 9 Radnor Street, Glasgow G3 7UA Interconnecting Sauchiehall Street and Argyle Street in Glasgow’s West End, the somewhat le... Read more.