THE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES OF REMOVING THE BEER-TIE FOR THE SCOTTISH PUB TRADE – STUART ROSS – FORMER BELHAVEN BOSS

May 17th, 2018 | Posted in: Editors' Picks

Having spent most of my entire working life in the Scottish Licensed Trade, I was very interested to read (Dram Issue No 330) the views of both the Pubs Advisory Service ( “ PAS “ ) and the Scottish Beer and Pubs Association (“SBPA” ) on the Neil Bibby Bill which proposes to introduce Market Rent Only (“MRO”) measures which effectively remove the beer tie in the tenanted sector of the pub trade.

My view is that, however well-intentioned this proposal might be, this piece of legislation will have serious unintended consequences and will not prove beneficial for the landlord or the tenant in the medium term. At first sight, it looks great for the tenant as, simplistically, he or she will be able to buy beer cheaper at the expense of paying a bit more in rent.

The majority of landlords are in the tenanted sector to secure some measure of control of supply in the beer sector as well as achieving an acceptable return on capital through the dual income streams of rent and supply profit. If their right to control beer supply and make profit is denied them, the probability is that they will come out of the tenanted sector altogether or radically reduce their involvement in it. Tenancy durations will be reduced to shortish-term lets (unlike England there is no security of tenure for tenants as the Landlord & Tenant laws do not apply north of the border ). Tenants who take the MRO route are unlikely to be offered continuity of tenure at the end of their contract. Property owners will switch the better-facilitated houses to managed retail or introduce more complex franchises or similar-such arrangements .

Capital investment will decline and I suspect that many of the larger property owners will reduce the number of tenancies in their Scottish portfolio to a level below whatever artificial threshold is applied to the new laws. ( In England, the law does not apply unless the landlord has more than 500 pubs. Since there are a host of regional brewers below the threshold, their tenants may well be aggrieved that they cannot go free-of-tie but local competitor tenants can do so simply because their pubs are owned by bigger property companies with more than 500 units. It`s an artificial and unfair playing field, from whichever angle you address it ).

In my opinion, this legislation will see the demise of the tenanted house model which, admittedly not perfect, has offered a huge opportunity for first-time operators to dip their toes into the pub game without the need for significant funding/financing, thus reducing risk for the newcomers. During my lengthy spell at Belhaven, we saw (and helped) many tenants progress to freehold ownership and become successful multiple-unit operators. Wearing my Montpeliers (non-executive) hat, we used the tenanted model in the early days to help build a solid foundation of café bars in the heart of Edinburgh. More recently, operators such as Kained Holdings in Glasgow and Andrina Bowes in Edinburgh have used the tenanted model to showcase their impressive skills in modernising a portfolio of community pubs.

I would challenge PAS`s claim that free-of-tie tenants will be able to secure funds to meaningfully invest into their pubs to create the end product of their vision. On short-term lets with no bricks-and-mortar to proffer as security? I think not, at best they may be able to attract smallish amounts of Advance Discounts from beer suppliers. But this carries a beer-tie with it and the balance on the Advance has to be repaid when the tenancy contract ends, so the tenant is back to square one.

I also think it is grossly misleading for PAS to claim that consumer choice will widen as a result of this Bill. Most pub landlords offer their tenants a wide variety of choice from a broad range of beer brand owners. The tenant picks the brands that his or her consumers want to drink. If a MRO tenant has to split modest beer volumes between five or six brand owners, the price benefit of being free-of-tie will quickly dissipate.

The fundamental problem with this type of legislation is that it impinges on free-market arrangements. The market always reacts to interference, one way or another. People my age remember The Supply of Beer Orders 1989 which were designed to break the “monopoly” of the then big six brewers by restricting the number of pubs they were able to own to an artificial limit. The purpose of the UK parliament was to widen consumer choice. What happened? Within a few years the big six brewers were all in the hands of foreign owners (no doubt hitting the considerable UK tax take in the process) and the trade saw the spawning of two massive property companies who dominated the tenanted sector and created business models which were deemed by many to be far too one-sided, compared to the previous “ beer landlord `s“ style and culture of operation. Unintended consequencies.

Things have changed since these days. Successful landlords know that it is in their interest for their tenanted publicans to earn good money from their pubs. The share of economic profit from the property and its operation has to be balanced and fair.

The old adage of “Be Careful What You Wish For” sprang to my mind when I first read Neil Bibby`s proposal. It is supported by many different and highly respected groups and individuals, all understandably anxious about the beer pricing issue. My anxiety is more focused on the inevitable “unintended consequencies” of the MRO introduction.


Which Scottish pub excels at customer service?

Thu 18th April 2019

Customer service is paramount when it comes to running a successful business. BII Scotland is on the lookout for a pub, restaurant or hotel ... Read more.

Which Scottish pub wins the woof and wag test?

Thu 18th April 2019

The Scottish Bar & Pub Awards is hunting for a pub that provides a welcome for pet dogs.... Read more.

Desperately Seeking the Greatest Scottish Bars and Pubs

Thu 18th April 2019

Scotland’s home to some of the best pubs and bars in the world but ‘which bars and pubs have made an impression on Scottish cust... Read more.

Do you know a budding Scottish entrepreneur? Are you one?

Thu 18th April 2019

Buzzworks and Flow are partnering to offer one emerging entrepreneur the opportunity to be mentored by one of the industry’s most experien... Read more.

Sue Says! Straight talking from our very own publisher

Thu 18th April 2019

Research from Rotary Great Britain claims that more than half of all UK adults are lonely, particularly when they get home from work. Perhap... Read more.

HIGH FRYERS: SCOTLAND’S CHEF-PATRONS MAKING THEIR MARK ON THE SCOTTISH CULINARY SCENE

Thu 18th April 2019

NEIL FORBES Cafe St Honore, Edinburgh and JUDITH FISH The Applecross Inn, Strathcarron... Read more.

Scottish hospitality industry unites to demand fair rates for all

Wed 17th April 2019

Glasgow’s hospitality industry has been unfairly discriminated against by rates assessors. That’s the view of industry bodies, Scottish ... Read more.

ABERDEENSHIRE GIN WINS GOLD AT WORLD SPIRITS COMPETITION

Wed 17th April 2019

HRAFN GIN  has won a Gold Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition. HRAFN GIN ‘Thought & Memory’, created in 2... Read more.

HIGH FRYERS: SCOTLAND’S CHEF-PATRONS MAKING THEIR MARK ON THE SCOTTISH CULINARY SCENE

Wed 17th April 2019

Here are the first two, FRED BERKMILLER OF l’escargot bleu, Edinburgh and MARK GREENAWAY Grazing by Mark Greenaway, Edinburgh.... Read more.

Star Pubs & Bars extend recycling agreement to leased estate

Tue 16th April 2019

Star Pubs & Bars is offering its leased pubs the same commercial terms for recycling and waste collection it has negotiated for its Just... Read more.

British Embassy adds Edinburgh chef to the menu in South America

Mon 15th April 2019

Edinburgh chef, Barry Bryson, is representing Scotland in a series of  events hosted by the British Embassy in Uruguay, South America, ... Read more.

Sunshine boost for pubs and restaurants

Mon 15th April 2019

Britain’s managed pub and restaurant groups saw collective like-for-like sales grow 3.8% in March compared to the same month last year whe... Read more.

Organic Wine Forecasted to Reach 87.5m Cases Globally by 2022 European Markets Drive Demand and Growth

Mon 15th April 2019

Though organic wines represent a small subset of the total global still wine industry, new research from IWSR Drinks Market Analysis shows a... Read more.

Are you an aspiring young Scottish chef? Then you should apply for the Andrew Fairlie Scholarship

Thu 11th April 2019

 As the application process opens for the inaugural Andrew Fairlie Scholarship, Hospitality Industry Trust (HIT) Scotland announce the ... Read more.

Scots chef isn’t sheepish about hogget

Thu 11th April 2019

A leading Scottish chef is championing a new campaign to revive a traditional springtime dish. Derek Johnstone, Head Chef at Borthwick Castl... Read more.

Civerinos Food Club opens ‘pizza pub’ on third site

Thu 11th April 2019

Edinburgh-based Civerinos Food Club has opened its third site in the city – The High Dive pizza bar. The new “pizza pub” is on St ... Read more.

Highland Park and SCRAPbook collaboration set to help clean up Orkney coastline

Wed 10th April 2019

Orkney is set to become the first Scottish island to be photographed from the air in a project that will help local communities tackle the g... Read more.

HAPPY 300th BIRTHDAY BELHAVEN!

Wed 10th April 2019

Belhaven Brewery recently celebrated 300 years of brewing excellence with a reception at the Scottish Parliament, hosted by East Lothian MSP... Read more.

KNOPFLER COLLABORATES ON GIN

Tue 9th April 2019

 Portobello Road Gin has collaborated with rock musician and Dire Straits frontman, Mark Knopfler, to launch a special edition gin for ... Read more.

New design crowns Kingshouse

Tue 9th April 2019

The £12m Kingshouse in Glencoe has been unveiled – and what a transformation. It was designed by Covell Matthews Architects for owners Bl... Read more.