Key to the Loch: licensee interview with Sandy Fraser

December 5th, 2018 | Posted in: Editors' Picks



Gabriel Oak is a character in Thomas Hardy’s Far From the Madding Crowd. As the name suggests, he’s the sturdy, reliable character at the centre of the story. Sandy Fraser cuts a similar figure at The Oak Tree Inn at Balmaha, on the east side of Loch Lomond, where’s he has been licensee and central to its success story for 21 years. Wife Lucy is also a big part of the business, which they built from nothing to a turnover of £3m, plus it now also employs several of his seven children and a further 100 employees across all the businesses. Yes there’s more to Sandy and Lucy Fraser than merely the Oak Tree Inn.

I caught up with Sandy and son Stuart, a partner in the business at The ‘Balmaha Experience’, as Sandy calls it. It’s not the first time I’ve interviewed Sandy: we first met seven years ago. But the business has grown considerably since then and now incorporates The Village Shop, Loch Lomond luxury ice-cream company, accommodation pods and several holiday cottages. They’ve also purchased a boat for tours as well as a proposed sail-by coffee shop (like McMonagles sail-by chippy in Clydebank should be). And if that wasn’t enough for anyone’s plate they also have planning permission for a new Oak Tree-sized building on the land just past the Oak Tree, on the right hand-side as you round the Loch, plus they a own quarry from which they mine the beautiful stone that clads many of the buildings they own.

Stuart, together with brother David, own and operate the St Mocha Coffee Shop, Loch Lomond Coffee Company, suppliers of the St Mocha Coffee Shop and a wee kiosk in Luss. And the brothers have been on the acquisition trail once more, as Sandy explained, “We want to make Balmaha the way that it was in the 50s and 60s when it was a destination, but we made a pledge at the start of the year that we’d be making no more acquisitions this year in order to focus on this. But we can’t turn down a good opportunity when it presents itself, which is what happened back in February when we acquired The Blane Valley in Strathblane. It’s a former Greene King tenanted unit and the plan is to return it into a country pub with an added coffee element, because like many pubs it is struggling. It’s very much a work-in-progress.”

He continued, “In late 2016 Stuart and David also purchased The Carbeth Inn in Carbeth. There are going to be a number of elements to the building/ site including a detached drive-through coffee shop. The main building will be renamed The Halfway House (its former name), for which we have full planning permission. Eventually this will also include accommodation and we’ll be running a pop-up by May next year with the completion of phase one set for 2020. It’s going to be like a kind of artisan Starbucks. In August Stuart and David purchased the old station buildings on Main Street Aberfoyle, and the plan is to turn this into a coffee shop with an added gift shop element. This is the gateway to the Trossachs and it was once a busy wee hub with a direct railway line from Glasgow.”

But it hasn’t all been a picnic in the last wee while. Said Sandy, “Staffing has been hellish for us. For the first time in 20 years there’s a lack of European staff and so we’ve been forced to recruit through agencies, and by signing up to agencies the staff can be getting paid up to double. We actually went to Lithuania to do presentations for students at the University of Vilnius and managed to get one of the lecturers to come here to work for us and she has been here for four years. She acts as a go-between. We’re not necessarily an academy per se, (this is something we’re looking at in the future). We do, however, provide accommodation in the pods, and that of course is one of the biggest challenges in rural hotels, the lack of accommodation, i.e. not just a pile of sheds and caravans.”

Sandy’s also seen a big shift in customer behaviour since we last spoke back in 2011. He said, “The 5pm trade in rural pubs is dead. The stricter drink driving laws have meant that most people won’t drink at all if they do go out. But in the main it’s more cultural I suppose– gone are the days when punters would go out for a couple and then go back for tea at about 7pm. A by-product of this is the closure of rural pubs. Just looking around our vicinity you can see evidence of this. One pub has closed in Buchlyvie and the last one is currently on the market, Croftamie’s only pub closed 18 months ago and had been on the market for over a year. The Black Bull in Killearn is also shut. “But we aren’t wasting time trying to endlessly figure out why customers aren’t behaving in the same way. We are focussing on new ways of operating, because if we don’t change we won’t be here. We do think that coffee shops are the pubs of the future.”

And Stuart and Sandy are also adding their voices to the growing chorus of licensees that are becoming more vocal about how grossly unfair the rates system is. Said Sandy, “Rates are absolutely crippling and this is one of the most worrying parts of our operation because we have an element of control over the other business challenges. But not this. They are penalising success, which is the same as killing the goose that lays the golden egg.” Stuart thinks that there should be more of a united front among people in the trade when it comes to fighting such iniquities. He said, “There’s strength in numbers and we feel that the hospitality industry should have one single body to fight for this type of thing. Margins are so very tight for everybody right now and we absolutely need a champion in our corner.”

He continued, “What is happening now is very, very worrying. Paying higher wages means a poorer quality product, which is why we’re trying to simplify things by doing it all on site by building a centralised kitchen, and recognising and doing something about the skills shortage we’re facing. Us being up at 25% on a wages bill is a ticking time-bomb – what next?  £20 for burger and chips?”

They’ve also had to shelve a few projects for the time being. Said Sandy, “We bottled our own Balmaha whisky. We do have plans for a brewery but mothballed it because we became a victim of our own success. It was borne out of necessity, in the early stages of the micro-brewery and craft beer boom in 2011. But since then, the Fallen Brewery and Loch Lomond have come to prominence, both of which we use. When we applied for planning permission, which we got, we originally put in for a one-barrel plant where we should have put in a ten-barrel plant.”

He continued, “The first run for the whisky was 300 bottles. I made the contacts with the master distillers through my electrician business. We worked on design and concept and outsourced the bottling. We’re currently waiting to rebottle because we have sold out.” And they’re also looking to adapting to new and emerging trends at their core business, The Oak Tree Inn. Said Stuart, “We’re looking at turning the menu 50% vegan over the next two years and, once finished, the centralised kitchen will serve the entire business – restaurant/retail/coffee shop – so that we have consistency across the business, which can be incredibly hard to achieve, like when creative differences with chefs crop up.”

But I’m sure Sandy et al will prevail because this man and his family are so very determined and never let setbacks or a lack of support deter them, like the lack of parking provision on the east side of the Loch for instance. Explained Sandy, “The powers that be seem happy for it to continue to be marketed as the ‘quiet side of the Loch’. For example, our own car park hasn’t been added to at all in parallel with the growth of our business. That’s why we have built a new pontoon to attract new visitors via the water.” In fact, it strikes me that the greater the resistance they come up against, the greater the Frasers’ business drive, so look out for interview number three in the next few years for the next update, when the Oak Tree Inn celebrates another milestone

Whitbread announces £500m share buyback programme

Thu 17th January 2019

Whitbread investors are to share in the Coca-Cola deal with a £500 million share buyback programme after the sale of Costa for £3.9 billio... Read more.

Quiet Man Taverns appoint first executive head chef

Wed 16th January 2019

An Edinburgh-based pub group has appointed the award-winning William Thomson as its first group executive head chef.... Read more.

Edinburgh Whisky Academy launches Introduction to Whisky Certificate

Tue 15th January 2019

The Edinburgh Whisky Academy, which is fully accredited by the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA), has launched their first tier of e... Read more.

Tue 15th January 2019

Belhaven owner Greene King has appointed Nick Mackenzie as its new chief executive. Mackenzie will join the company on 1 May, succeeding Roo... Read more.

Oli Norman buys Stephen White out

Tue 15th January 2019

Oli Norman has taken full control of the seven-strong pub business that he and Stephen White built. ... Read more.

Oran Mor unveils Tam O’Shanter paintings

Tue 15th January 2019

Glasgow’s Oran Mor has unveiled 10 new paintings by Scottish artist Nichol Wheatley depicting the most memorable scenes from Tam OR... Read more.

Bridge of Don bar’s customers raise £650 for local neighbourhood park

Mon 14th January 2019

Customers at The Brig Inn on Aberdeen’s Balgownie Road have raised £650 for their local neighbourhood park (Friends of Seaton Park)... Read more.

Makeover for Edinburgh’s Scottish Cafe & Restaurant

Thu 10th January 2019

Edinburgh’s Scottish Cafe & Restaurant has closed for a major redevelopment, as part of the £22m National Galleries of Scotland Collecti... Read more.

Highland Pubs buck UK-wide closure trend

Tue 8th January 2019

Here's a reason for licensees to be cheerful in what might be an otherwise challenging month, well those in the far north of Scotland at any... Read more.

Two hospitality-related MBEs for Scots in 2019 New Year Honours

Tue 8th January 2019

More than 100 Scots have been included on the Queen’s New Year Honours List 2019, including two MBEs for hospitality-related services.... Read more.

Highland family go from field to fork

Tue 8th January 2019

The Coach House Bar and Restaurant in Dornoch has been acquired by husband and wife team Tommy and Audrey Mackay in a reported six-figure de... Read more.


Tue 8th January 2019

Business partners Les Ross, Lewis Boddy and Mark Klose have opened a new late-night venue in Dumfries called The Hi-Hat, in the upper floor ... Read more.

Fife Arms Hotel gets it down to a fine art

Tue 8th January 2019

The 46-bedroom Fife Arms Hotel in Braemar is now officially open, and leading the team is General Manager, Federica Bertolini, who joined fr... Read more.

Design focus: Jax Bar-Eatery

Tue 8th January 2019

The 80s revival shows no signs of hanging up its legwarmers if the design of Jax Bar-Eatery in Glasgow’s Princes Square is any gauge. Thin... Read more.

Design focus: Bertie’s

Tue 8th January 2019

A neon sign displaying the legend ‘Fry Me to the Moon’ is one of many wonderfully quirky touches in Bertie’s – the Vittoria Group’... Read more.

Licensee interview: Marco Arcari and Mario Arcari

Tue 8th January 2019

Even sitting down for a coffee with father and son team Marco Arcari, 51, and Mario Arcari, 28, screams quality. It’s beautifully presente... Read more.

Greene King reports like-for-likes up 10.9% over Christmas fortnight

Tue 8th January 2019

Belhaven owner Greene King has reported like-for-like sales over the two weeks to Christmas were up 10.9%. After 36 weeks of its financial y... Read more.

Sales of Buckfast hit record high

Mon 7th January 2019

Sales of Buckfast have hit a record high with further growth expected this year following the introduction of minimum pricing in Scotland.... Read more.

AB InBev makes changes to UK and Ireland senior management team

Mon 7th January 2019

Anheuser-Busch InBev (AB InBev) has reshuffled its UK and Ireland senior management team as part of organisational changes designed to captu... Read more.


Mon 7th January 2019

A team of top Scottish chefs including Trump Turnberry’s pastry chef, Andrew MacKay (pictured), has served up a winning menu at the Viller... Read more.