MINIMUM PRICING IS LEGAL COURT RULES

November 15th, 2017 | Posted in: News

The Scottish Government has won its five-year fight to bring in Minimum Unit Pricing (MUP) to Scotland, which will make it the first country in Europe to do so. The top court in the land, the UK Supreme Court, ruled that Scotland can set a minimum price for alcohol, rejecting a challenge by the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA).

In a unanimous judgment, seven Supreme Court judges said the proposed legislation did not breach European Union law. The judges ruled the measure was a “proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim”.

Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon tweeted, “Absolutely delighted that minimum pricing has been upheld by the Supreme Court. This has been a long road – and no doubt the policy will continue to have its critics – but it is a bold and necessary move to improve public health.”

The proposed MUP of 50p per unit of alcohol now looks likely to be introduced as early as next April.

The Scotch Whisky Association, which had fought the legislation for five years on behalf of its members, said it accepted the Supreme Court’s ruling. Karen Betts, Scotch Whisky Association chief executive, said, “We accept the Supreme Court’s ruling on minimum unit pricing (MUP) of alcohol in Scotland. Looking ahead, the Scotch Whisky industry will continue to work in partnership with the government and the voluntary sector to promote responsible drinking and to tackle alcohol-related harm.”

Paul Bartlett, Group Corporate Relations Director, Tennent’s owners, C&C Group, which supported MUP commented, “C&C Group plc has been a strong and vocal supporter of Minimum Unit Pricing since it was first proposed in 2011. We welcome today’s landmark decision. It is the right move to make; a progressive step forward in tackling the problems of alcohol misuse in Scotland and we congratulate the Scottish Government on its perseverance.”

He continued, “Although the majority of Scots enjoy alcohol responsibly, we are concerned about the availability of strong, cheap alcohol and its correlation with harmful drinking that causes misery across Scotland. As part of a package of measures, Minimum Unit Pricing will help to address this.

“Now that the Supreme Court have made their ruling, we urge the industry to get behind the decision. We’ll be working with the Scottish Government and our customers over the coming months to support the successful introduction of Minimum Unit Pricing.”

Paul Waterson, Chief Executive of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association, who also supported Minimum Unit Pricing commented, “The relationship between low prices and increased consumption is obvious. Supermarkets strategy of using alcohol as a loss leader, very often charging prices cheaper than water, which is totally irresponsible, is a major factor in causing much of the alcohol abuse we see in Scotland today. Minimum pricing will be a major element in eradicating these problems.”

“Cheap priced alcohol has turned Scotland into a nation of stay at home drinkers.  72% of total alcohol sales in Scotland are off sales, 80% of this total is sold by supermarkets. When people drink in uncontrolled environments alcohol related problems increase significantly.”

He concluded, “Our market needed intervention to bring back price stability. The market could not correct itself – it needed robust government action. The only efficient way of doing that is by minimum pricing. We applaud the Scottish Government for their policy .”

“Already this year we have seen in the run up to Christmas many television adverts advertising irresponsible supermarket deals on alcohol which will seduce people into drinking more than they would normally. Thanks to this legislation loss leading of alcohol at child friendly prices will become a thing of the past.”


It’s time to vote for Pub of the Year 2019 or to get your customers to vote for you

Thu 18th April 2019

This year the Sunday Mail Pub of the Year Award will go to the ‘best of the best’ at this year’s Scottish Bar and Pub Awards. This... Read more.

Do you think you know the best cocktail bar in Scotland or do you think you ARE the best Cocktail Bar in Scotland?

Thu 18th April 2019

If so why not enter the Tia Maria Cocktail Bar of the Year category at this year’s Scottish Bar and Pub Awards? Judges will be looking... Read more.

Are you a social media savvy business?

Thu 18th April 2019

Social Media is very important when it comes to promoting your business and hollicom and the Scottish Bar and Pub awards 2019 want to hear f... Read more.

Which Scottish beer bar is king?

Thu 18th April 2019

Molson Coors and Judges from the Scottish Bar and Pub Awards are looking for Beer Bar of the Year. will be looking for an outlet with a rang... Read more.

Step forward Scotland’s best new bar

Thu 18th April 2019

Kopparberg is on the lookout for Scotland’s best new bar as part of the Scottish Bar and Pub Awards 2019. The Kopparberg team is looking f... Read more.

Calling all environmentally conscious hospitality businesses

Thu 18th April 2019

Sea Change is a range of environmentally conscious wines that are now being distributed by Inverarity Morton and this year, in the same spir... Read more.

Do you run Scotland’s best Hotel Bar? Would you like to nominate one?

Thu 18th April 2019

Hotel Scotland, Scotland’s only dedicated hotel publication, is on the lookout for Hotel Bar of the Year as part of the Scottish Bar and P... Read more.

We want to hear from you if you run Scotland’s best whisky bar

Thu 18th April 2019

Gordon & MacPhail’s Connoisseur’s Choice range gives a platform to many of Scotland’s single malt distilleries from across all reg... Read more.

We’re looking to crown Scotland’s best casual dining experience

Thu 18th April 2019

The Scottish Bar and Pub Awards 2019 is looking for a restaurant that also boasts a bar, that has created the perfect ambiance and food offe... Read more.

Which Scottish pub excels at customer service?

Thu 18th April 2019

Customer service is paramount when it comes to running a successful business. BII Scotland is on the lookout for a pub, restaurant or hotel ... Read more.

Which Scottish pub wins the woof and wag test?

Thu 18th April 2019

The Scottish Bar & Pub Awards is hunting for a pub that provides a welcome for pet dogs.... Read more.

Desperately Seeking the Greatest Scottish Bars and Pubs

Thu 18th April 2019

Scotland’s home to some of the best pubs and bars in the world but ‘which bars and pubs have made an impression on Scottish cust... Read more.

Do you know a budding Scottish entrepreneur? Are you one?

Thu 18th April 2019

Buzzworks and Flow are partnering to offer one emerging entrepreneur the opportunity to be mentored by one of the industry’s most experien... Read more.

Sue Says! Straight talking from our very own publisher

Thu 18th April 2019

Research from Rotary Great Britain claims that more than half of all UK adults are lonely, particularly when they get home from work. Perhap... Read more.

HIGH FRYERS: SCOTLAND’S CHEF-PATRONS MAKING THEIR MARK ON THE SCOTTISH CULINARY SCENE

Thu 18th April 2019

NEIL FORBES Cafe St Honore, Edinburgh and JUDITH FISH The Applecross Inn, Strathcarron... Read more.

Scottish hospitality industry unites to demand fair rates for all

Wed 17th April 2019

Glasgow’s hospitality industry has been unfairly discriminated against by rates assessors. That’s the view of industry bodies, Scottish ... Read more.

ABERDEENSHIRE GIN WINS GOLD AT WORLD SPIRITS COMPETITION

Wed 17th April 2019

HRAFN GIN  has won a Gold Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition. HRAFN GIN ‘Thought & Memory’, created in 2... Read more.

HIGH FRYERS: SCOTLAND’S CHEF-PATRONS MAKING THEIR MARK ON THE SCOTTISH CULINARY SCENE

Wed 17th April 2019

Here are the first two, FRED BERKMILLER OF l’escargot bleu, Edinburgh and MARK GREENAWAY Grazing by Mark Greenaway, Edinburgh.... Read more.

Star Pubs & Bars extend recycling agreement to leased estate

Tue 16th April 2019

Star Pubs & Bars is offering its leased pubs the same commercial terms for recycling and waste collection it has negotiated for its Just... Read more.

British Embassy adds Edinburgh chef to the menu in South America

Mon 15th April 2019

Edinburgh chef, Barry Bryson, is representing Scotland in a series of  events hosted by the British Embassy in Uruguay, South America, ... Read more.